FHA Loan vs. Conventional Loan — Which Is Right for You?
One of the most common questions homebuyers face is: should I go FHA or conventional? The answer depends on your credit score, down payment, and long-term goals. Here’s a direct comparison.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | FHA Loan | Conventional Loan |
|---|---|---|
| Minimum Credit Score | 580 (standard) | Typically 620–640 |
| Minimum Down Payment | 3.5% | 3% (some programs) |
| Mortgage Insurance | UFMIP + monthly MIP required | PMI if < 20% down |
| MI Cancellation | Life of loan (if < 10% down) | Removal can be requested at 80% LTV; automatic at 78% LTV if payments are current |
| Max Seller Concessions | 6% | 3%–9% depending on LTV |
| Property Types | Primary residence only | Primary, second home, investment |
| Gift Funds | Allowed — 100% of down payment | Allowed with restrictions |
When FHA Makes More Sense
- Lower credit scores: If your score is 580–660, FHA typically offers better rates and easier approval than conventional.
- Limited down payment: At 3.5%, FHA requires similar down payment to many conventional programs — but with easier credit requirements.
- Recent derogatory events: FHA waiting periods after bankruptcy (2 years) and foreclosure (3 years) are shorter than conventional (4 years and 7 years respectively).
- Gift funds for the full down payment: FHA is extremely accommodating for gift money.
When Conventional Makes More Sense
- Higher credit scores with equity: If your credit is 720+ and you have 20% down, conventional avoids mortgage insurance entirely.
- Long-term MIP concern: FHA MIP doesn’t cancel automatically with equity growth on loans with less than 10% down.
- Second homes and investment properties: FHA is only for primary residences.
The Bottom Line
There is no universally “better” option. For a first-time buyer in California with a 600 credit score and 3.5% saved, FHA is likely the right answer. For a buyer with 740 credit and 20% down, conventional is almost always better. Many buyers fall somewhere in between — that’s where working with a broker who can compare both options for you becomes critical.
How to compare the two fairly
Ask for both options on the same purchase price, down payment and lock period, then line up four numbers: the monthly payment including mortgage insurance, the cash to close, the upfront costs, and the total cost over the years you expect to keep the loan. A lower interest rate does not always mean a lower payment once insurance is included.
Why mortgage insurance pricing differs
FHA monthly insurance depends on loan amount, term and LTV, as the mortgage insurance guide shows, not on your credit score. Conventional PMI is priced on both LTV and score. As a result, borrowers with stronger scores often find conventional PMI cheaper, while borrowers with lower scores may find FHA less expensive. FHA also adds a 1.75% upfront premium; illustrative example: on a $500,000 base loan that is $8,750, usually financed into the loan.
Options that sit between the two
Buyers who assume conventional means 20% down overlook programs such as HomeReady and Home Possible, which allow 3% down for eligible borrowers, subject to income limits. They can narrow the gap with FHA for buyers with solid credit.
The exit plan matters
Many FHA borrowers plan to refinance into a conventional loan once they reach about 20% equity, which removes the monthly insurance. Conventional PMI can be requested off at 80% of the original value and ends automatically at 78% when payments are current. If you expect strong income growth or home appreciation, ask us to price the refinance exit alongside the purchase.
Frequently asked questions
Which program allows a higher debt-to-income ratio?
Both can go to roughly 50% with an automated approval and strong compensating factors. The difference is usually credit score and reserves, so run your file through both.
Is the appraisal different?
FHA appraisals evaluate property condition against FHA standards, while conventional appraisals focus more on value. A home with deferred maintenance can be easier to finance conventionally.
Can I switch after I start the process?
Yes, before closing. Changing the loan product restarts disclosure timing, so it is better to compare both options at the beginning.
Related guides
- What is a conventional loan
- Conventional PMI
- FHA mortgage insurance
- VA versus FHA versus conventional
- FHA calculator